BeautyGARDE Oil-Free Mascara - safe for lash extensions, lengthens and thickens

The product was easy to use and honestly beautiful. No clumping, but a little difficult to remove. Used on eyelash extensions.

I don't really like this mascara. Not sure if it was an old tube or if this is just how the mascara is. But it seemed dry and clumpy, making it hard to apply to the actual lash. I seemed to get more on myself than on my actual eyelashes. Also doesn't last all day.

Very disappointed. This mascara was like glue on my lashes, extremely difficult to remove even with repeated washing. It clumped together and my lashes wouldn't separate even brushing them with a dry lash brush. It ruined my lashes extensions, I ended up having to have them removed and redone.

I wear lash extensions and every now and then (between fills) you need a little extra. I bought the mascara and liner for such the occasion. The mascara was so dry, and putty-like and was difficult to apply... Too dry and YES, this is day one, fresh out of the box. It was the complete opposite for the liner. It went on wet, very fluid but didn’t dry fast. The felt tip is tiny, skinny and flimsy (no control). I could never apply my line just right. The liner smudges and looks like a drugstore brand. Lastly, I had my first lash fill-in after using this product one time and my lash tech ripped me a new on. Even after safely removing the product, it’s not really ever gone. My tech said while it’s oil-fee the product left a film on my extensions that causes the extensions to become too heavy and will eventually breakdown the adhesive and leads to premature lash loss. So yeah, I ruined my e$pensive set of extensions thinking that I was using a lash extension safe product. So, yeah, big let down. :-(

Costs less than my designer brand mascara and works just as well! Some reviews mentioned clumping which I did not experience. My eyelashes held a curl well after applying the mascara which is hard to find.

I've never bought a mascara specifically for extensions except the black diamond coat which really just gets rid of the powdery look from your eyeshadow, and doesn't really add volume. So know this review is based off ALL the mostly high-end mascaras I've used. Pros: Doesn't smudge, nor smear. Smells decent. Looks natural. Washes off like a dream. Cons: expensive. Very flat looking. Brush isn't stellar (bristles not as pictured)...not really sure if maybe I haven't mastered it. Doesn't really clump as a product, but is waxy and lashes don't separate nicely even after using a spooly. Verdict: I'd keep it for days I'm just going to work or the gym and don't really need something stellar if I can master the brush. If I happen to try a similar product with better or worse results, will update my review accordingly. Gave it 4 stars because it's gorgeous product packaging. Product is 3.5.

It kinda has the consistency of dried out mascara. Not sure if that is normal or if I just got an old tube. 🤷🏼‍♀️ Because of the consistency it takes a lot to build up. But if that’s what it takes to help keep my extensions, so be it.

Great to remove for eyelash extensions, my Specialist loves this brand! Never a problem with the application or removal!